"Vividness" isn't a Photoshop tool
Worth clearing up first: there's no Vividness slider in Photoshop. It's a general, colloquial word for how punchy or intense an image's colors look overall, and that perception is the result of more than one thing working together, not a single adjustable value. Keep that in mind, because it's exactly why maxing out Saturation to chase "more vividness" often backfires.
Saturation: uniform, blunt, and hard on skin tones
Saturation increases every color in the image by the same amount, regardless of how saturated it already is. Push it far enough and already-strong colors clip or band, since there's less room left to push them before they hit a hard ceiling. Skin tones take the worst of it: they already sit in a fairly saturated red-orange range, so a uniform saturation boost pushes faces toward orange fast, well before the rest of the image looks meaningfully more colorful.
Vibrance: selective, and specifically built to protect skin
Vibrance boosts muted, less-saturated colors more than it boosts colors that are already strong, and it specifically restrains skin tones as part of how it's built. In a portrait, that means the background and clothing can get noticeably richer while the face stays natural, because Vibrance is recognizing skin as already-saturated-enough and treating it differently from the rest of the frame, instead of applying one flat multiplier to everything.
So what actually creates "vividness"?
In practice, what reads as a "vivid" image is usually saturation or vibrance working together with contrast, especially local contrast (the kind Clarity or Dehaze-style adjustments add). A well-saturated image that's flat in contrast still reads as dull. A contrast-punchy image can look vivid even at fairly moderate saturation, because the eye reads color intensity partly through contrast, not purely through the saturation value itself. Chasing "more vividness" by only pushing the saturation slider harder is frequently the wrong lever to pull.
Practical guidance
Default to Vibrance for most images, it's more forgiving, protects skin tones automatically, and carries less risk of banding in already-colorful areas like a saturated sky. Reach for Saturation only when you deliberately want a uniform, flat intensity push, a stylized graphic look, for instance, and you're accepting the tradeoffs that come with it. If the actual goal is a punchier, more "vivid" feeling image rather than literally more saturated color, add contrast or local contrast separately instead of relying on the saturation slider to do that job alone.
Quick answers to a few related questions
Does Lightroom's Vibrance work the same way as Photoshop's?
Yes, it's the same underlying behavior, shared across Adobe's raw-processing and editing tools.
Can Vibrance still cause banding on some images?
It can, though it's less likely than with Saturation. Large, already partially-saturated flat areas, a smooth gradient sky, for example, are still the most vulnerable spot regardless of which slider you use.
Can I boost perceived vividness without touching saturation at all?
Yes. A contrast or Clarity-style local-contrast boost alone can make colors read as more vivid even with saturation left completely untouched, since the eye's perception of color intensity is genuinely tied to contrast, not just the saturation value.
EN
IT