"My adjustment is leaking into tones I didn't select"
This isn't a bug, it's how luminosity masks are supposed to work, just not how people expect. A luminosity mask isn't binary black-and-white. In the transition zone between the tones you targeted and the tones you didn't, the mask is gray, and gray partially reveals the adjustment underneath. That partial reveal is what gives luminosity-mask edits their smooth, self-feathering quality instead of a hard cutout line.
If you want a harder edge with less spillover, apply Levels directly to the mask and drag the input sliders inward to push more of that transition zone toward pure black or pure white. If some spillover is actually fine and you just want less of the effect overall, it's often better to leave the mask alone and pull back the adjustment layer's opacity instead.
"I don't know which mask (Lights-1, Lights-2...) to use"
Multi-level luminosity mask sets work by re-selecting from the previous mask: Lights isolates the brightest half of the tonal range, Lights-2 isolates the brightest half of that selection again, and so on, narrowing in on progressively brighter (or, on the Darks side, progressively darker) zones. Guessing which level you need from the name alone is genuinely hard.
Instead of guessing, load each candidate mask as a selection (Ctrl-click its thumbnail) and look at the marching ants directly on the image, or temporarily clip a high-contrast Threshold adjustment to it to see exactly what it's isolating before you commit. As a starting rule of thumb: begin with the broadest mask (Lights or Darks) and only step up to Lights-2 or Lights-3 if the first one is pulling in more midtone than you want.
"A masked adjustment layer affects the whole image, not just where I paint"
This is the difference between two related but distinct techniques, and mixing them up is an easy trap. A luminosity mask clipped to an adjustment layer selects every pixel in that tonal range, everywhere in the image, consistently. That's the right tool when you want a tonal range treated the same way throughout, like a global highlight recovery.
If you want the same kind of targeted brightening or darkening but only in one specific area, ignoring identical tones elsewhere in the frame, that's a job for manual brushing: paint with black or white at low opacity and flow directly onto a mask, building up the effect by hand in just that one spot. Both techniques use grayscale masks. The difference is whether the mask comes from an automated tonal selection (affects that tone everywhere) or a hand-painted one (affects only where you painted).
"I thought luminosity masks only worked with Curves"
They don't, and this misconception mostly comes from tutorials defaulting to Curves because of its fine control. A luminosity mask is just a grayscale mask clipped to whatever adjustment layer it's attached to. It works exactly the same way on Levels, Hue/Saturation, Photo Filter, Selective Color, Color Balance, or any other adjustment type. If Curves feels like overkill for a particular correction, use a simpler adjustment with the same mask instead.
"My exposure blend looks dull and gray instead of natural"
This usually isn't a mask problem, it's an exposure-gap problem. When the two exposures you're blending are too far apart in brightness, the transition zone between them loses local contrast: midtones from both exposures average out into a flat, drab gray exactly where the blend happens, even with a technically well-built mask.
Two ways around it: manually brush in some of that lost local contrast by hand with a soft, low-opacity brush directly on the mask, rebuilding definition in the transition zone the automated selection can't restore on its own. Or, if your source files have enough dynamic range to begin with, lean on Camera Raw's highlight and shadow recovery to close the exposure gap before you ever get to blending, since modern sensors often make an extreme two-exposure blend unnecessary in the first place.
"I don't know when to stop in Camera Raw and start using masks in Photoshop"
Get the broad strokes right in Camera Raw first: overall exposure, highlights, shadows, white and black points, so the image is reasonably balanced before it ever reaches Photoshop. Luminosity masks are the right tool for localized, tonal-range-specific refinement that ACR's global sliders can't target precisely, not for fixing an exposure that's fundamentally off to begin with. Trying to do both jobs with masks alone means fighting them to do more work than they're built for.
EN
IT