What the Luminance Range Mask actually does
It lives inside Camera Raw and Lightroom's three local adjustment tools, the Adjustment Brush, Graduated Filter and Radial Filter, as a Range Mask option set to Luminance. Two sliders define a tonal window: the left marker sets the darkest tones included, the right marker sets the lightest, and only the range between them gets affected by whatever local adjustment you're applying. A Smoothness slider controls how gradually the mask transitions at the edges of that window, and turning on the Visualize (or Show Luminance Mask) overlay renders the image in grayscale with a red highlight over exactly what's currently included, so you can see the mask before committing to it.
Why it's more limited than a true composite-channel mask
Scope. The Range Mask is always attached to one specific local adjustment tool instance. It isn't a standalone selection you can reuse; there's no equivalent of Ctrl-clicking the RGB composite thumbnail to pull the same tonal selection into an unrelated adjustment.
Refinement. You get one Smoothness slider for the transition. A true Photoshop luminosity mask can be reshaped with Levels or Curves into any falloff curve you want, and you can paint additive or subtractive exceptions directly onto it with a brush, neither of which the Range Mask supports.
Persistence. The Range Mask exists only inside that specific filter instance, on that specific local adjustment. A real Photoshop luminosity mask, saved as a channel or a layer mask, persists in the document and can be reloaded as a selection any number of times, for any number of different adjustments, in that same editing session.
Where the Range Mask is actually the right tool
For a fast, single local correction directly on the raw file, brighten just the sky within a Graduated Filter, but only the brightest part of it, it's genuinely well suited to the job. You get a live tonal selection with a visual preview, right where you're already working, with no need to open Photoshop at all.
Where you need a real luminosity mask instead
Once the same tonal selection needs to feed more than one adjustment, needs a transition shaped by Levels or Curves rather than a single Smoothness slider, needs hand-painted exceptions, or needs to still be there and reloadable later in the same Photoshop session, that's outside what the Range Mask is built to do, and it's time to build a real composite-channel mask.
Quick answers to a few related questions
Can I bring a Camera Raw local adjustment with a Range Mask into Photoshop as a real, editable mask?
Not directly. Once the image opens in Photoshop, the local adjustment is already baked into the rendered pixels (unless you're working through a Smart Object with an editable Camera Raw filter, and even then the Range Mask itself isn't exposed as a separate channel you can pull into a different adjustment).
Does the Visualize/Show Luminance Mask overlay help build a Photoshop mask too?
It's a useful way to check your thinking, but the overlay is a Camera Raw-only preview. It doesn't export as a mask or a selection you can carry into Photoshop.
Is the Smoothness slider the same as feathering a Photoshop mask with Gaussian Blur?
Conceptually similar, both soften a transition, but Smoothness is one global control for that one local adjustment, not a directly editable blur value you can dial in and adjust later the way you can with Gaussian Blur applied straight to a mask.
EN
IT