It's not a bug, it's Opacity doing exactly what Opacity does
Opacity sets a hard ceiling for a single stroke. Paint at 50% Opacity and scrub over the same spot as many times as you want within that one continuous stroke, it will never get darker than 50%, because the ceiling applies to the stroke as a whole, not to each individual pass. To go darker, you have to lift the pen or release the mouse button and start a completely new stroke.
That's exactly where the jump comes from. Two separate 50% strokes that overlap don't blend into a smooth gradient, they stack into a visible step: 50% where only one stroke touched, roughly 75% where both did, with a hard edge between the two zones instead of a gradual transition. It looks like the brush is misbehaving. It's actually behaving exactly as designed.
Flow is a completely different mechanism
Flow controls the rate paint builds up per pass, not a ceiling on the stroke. At 100% Opacity with a low Flow, say 4-10%, holding the button down and passing repeatedly over the same spot within one continuous stroke keeps adding density each time, smoothly climbing toward full black or white instead of stopping at a fixed cap. Because it's a continuous buildup rather than a series of discrete, separately-capped strokes, there's no hard edge for the "jump" to happen at.
The fix: 100% Opacity, low Flow, for anything you want to build up gradually
Set Opacity to 100% and Flow to somewhere around 4-10%, lower for finer control, higher for faster buildup. Paint in continuous passes without lifting the pen to build density exactly where and how much you want. This is the standard approach for gradually revealing or hiding part of a mask by hand, dodge-and-burn work, feathering in a manual exception, anything where you want the effect to deepen smoothly as you work rather than jump between the two abrupt states an Opacity-capped stroke produces.
When Opacity is actually still the right choice
For a single, perfectly even, flat reveal or hide in one pass, no gradual buildup needed, Opacity alone at a fixed value is simpler and does exactly one predictable thing per stroke. The problem only shows up when you're trying to use Opacity for the kind of gradual, multi-pass buildup that Flow is actually built for.
Quick answers to a few related questions
Does Airbrush mode change any of this?
Yes. With Airbrush mode enabled, Flow keeps building up over time even while you hold the brush still, based on how long you pause rather than how far you move. It's worth turning off if you want Flow's buildup tied strictly to brush movement.
Does brush hardness or spacing affect how visible the jump looks?
It can make the seam between separate Opacity-capped strokes more or less obvious, a hard, low-spacing brush shows a crisper edge at the overlap, a soft brush hides it somewhat, but the underlying cause is still Opacity's fixed ceiling, not the brush shape itself.
Is there a fast way to switch between Opacity and Flow values while painting?
Number keys 1 through 9 set Opacity in 10% steps (press 5 for 50%, 0 for 100%). Hold Shift and press a number key to set Flow the same way instead.
EN
IT