What Blend If actually is
Blend If lives in the Layer Style dialog (double-click a layer, or the fx menu at the bottom of the Layers panel), under "This Layer" and "Underlying Layer" sliders. It tells Photoshop, in effect, "hide this layer wherever its tones (or the layer below's tones) fall in this range." It's parametric: Photoshop stores the slider values as numbers and recalculates the result live, every time you view the layer, rather than baking anything into pixel data. That's also why it's easy to forget a layer even has it applied, since there's no separate mask thumbnail in the Layers panel to remind you, just a small fx icon.
What a luminosity mask actually is
A luminosity mask, by contrast, is real pixel data: a grayscale mask you build once (typically by Ctrl-clicking the RGB composite thumbnail), that sits in the Layers or Channels panel as its own paintable, refinable object. It doesn't recalculate if the layers below it change later, and it does add to file size, since it's an actual saved image, not a set of numbers.
The differences that actually matter
Transition shape. Blend If's feathering, even at its best, is a straight linear ramp between two slider points. A luminosity mask's transition can be reshaped with Levels or Curves into whatever falloff you want, linear or not.
No hand-painted exceptions. Once a Blend If rule is set, it applies uniformly wherever that tonal condition is true, everywhere in the layer. There's no way to manually protect or reveal one specific spot the way you can paint directly onto a mask.
What it can read. Blend If only reads the image's own existing channels, gray composite or individual RGB/CMYK channels depending on your color mode. A luminosity mask can be built from any criterion you can turn into a selection, including saturation, a specific hue range, or a hand-refined combination of several selections.
Cost and permanence. Blend If is effectively free in file size and stays live if the underlying layers change. A luminosity mask is fixed at the pixel state of the moment you built it and won't auto-update if you edit something below it afterward.
The trick that makes Blend If actually usable
The harsh, banded cutoff people associate with Blend If comes from using it with the slider handles left whole. Hold Alt (Option on Mac) and drag one half of a slider handle, and it splits into two separate triangles. Everything between those two points now feathers gradually instead of cutting off abruptly. It's still a straight linear ramp, not a custom curve, but splitting the handle removes most of what gives Blend If its bad reputation.
When to actually reach for each one
Use Blend If for fast, situational fixes on a single layer, hiding a blown highlight peeking through from a layer below, or quick tone-based compositing, especially when the underlying image isn't going to change again and you don't need to hand-paint any exceptions. It costs nothing in file size and takes seconds to set up.
Use a luminosity mask when you need a shaped, non-linear transition, want to refine or hand-paint exceptions into the selection, or need the mask built from something other than plain per-channel brightness, like saturation or a combined selection.
Quick answers to a few related questions
Can I convert a Blend If result into a real luminosity mask?
Not with a single click. The usual approach is to merge a stamped copy of the visible result onto a new layer and build a fresh mask from that, or simply rebuild the equivalent selection manually if you decide you need the extra control a real mask gives you.
Is Blend If non-destructive?
Yes, it's fully parametric and lives in the Layer Style, editable or removable at any time without touching a single pixel. A luminosity mask is also non-destructive to the underlying image, it just isn't as flexible in shape once built.
Does Blend If add anything to file size?
No. It's stored as a handful of numeric slider values in the layer's style data, not as pixel data, so it adds essentially nothing to the file compared to a saved luminosity mask.
EN
IT